Lists for people who do not have accounts

Some links on this page are paid links. If you buy through one, MyBaberz may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. See our Affiliate Disclosure.

Any system for coordinating gifts runs into the same wall eventually. It works beautifully for the people who signed up, and the people who most need a list are frequently not those people. A four year old cannot have an account. Someone in their eighties may have one and never open it. There is always at least one person who will simply never install anything, and being right about that does not help you.

Two different problems wearing the same coat

Someone who cannot maintain a list needs a person to keep it for them. A small child has opinions but cannot type them, and the opinions change weekly. Somebody has to be the author.

Someone who will not sign up can often maintain a list perfectly well, they just will not do it inside an app. They need a way to receive and use a list without an account existing at all.

These look similar from the outside and need opposite solutions. The first needs a managed list. The second needs a link that works with no account behind it.

Managed lists, and being honest about them

A managed list is a list one person keeps on behalf of another. It is how a child's list exists at all, and it works well as long as one thing is true: it is clearly labelled as managed.

The failure case is a list that looks like it came from the person when it did not. Somebody buys the specific thing on it, and it turns out to be the thing an adult wished the child wanted. Nobody is served by that. When a list is visibly kept by someone else, shoppers read it correctly, as a strong steer rather than a direct request, and they ask when they are unsure.

Two habits make managed lists much better. Date them, because a list for a three year old is wrong by the time they are four. And write down the constraints rather than only the items, because "no more stuffed animals, we are drowning" is more valuable to a shopper than any individual product.

The person who will not sign up

For them, every step you add is a step where they stop. The list has to arrive as a link that opens and works, and shows what is still available without asking who they are.

In Gifterz that is a guest link. It opens straight to the occasion, shows what is claimed and what is open, and lets someone claim an item without ever creating an account. Nobody has to be talked into anything, which is the entire point.

The tradeoff is real and worth knowing: a link that works without an account is a link anyone holding it can open. Send it to the people it is for, and expect it to expire.

Where this is worth the effort

Mostly with children, because the duplicate problem is at its worst there. A popular toy in a given year will be bought by three separate people who all had the same good idea, and the coordination that prevents that is exactly what a young child cannot do for themselves.

Worth noting for a managed list: all three are open ended rather than tied to a character or a phase, which is what keeps them in use after the novelty goes.