When two people buy the same thing

Some links on this page are paid links. If you buy through one, MyBaberz may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. See our Affiliate Disclosure.

Two people, independently, buy the same gift for the same person. Nobody did anything wrong. In fact the more accurate a list is, the more likely this becomes, because a good list points several thoughtful people at the same small set of items.

Why it happens to organised groups

Lists concentrate attention. Twelve items, and two or three are obviously the best. Everyone who reads the list carefully arrives at the same shortlist, which is the list working correctly.

Saying it out loud spoils it. The one place everybody talks is usually the one place the recipient can see, so claims get made quietly or not at all.

Intention is invisible. Someone decided three weeks ago, ordered nothing yet, and told nobody. From outside, that item is untouched.

Nothing is ever removed. A bought item usually stays on the list, because taking it off would tell the recipient what they are getting.

The fix is a claim the recipient cannot see

All four failures share one cause: the coordination has nowhere to live except a channel the recipient can read. Give it its own place and the problem mostly disappears.

The important part is that a claim has two states, not one. Reserved means somebody intends to buy it, which is the state that covers the three weeks between deciding and ordering. Bought means it is done. Shoppers see both. The recipient sees neither, until the occasion is over.

A reservation should be treated as a soft hold with a clock on it. Without one, half the list ends up reserved by people who changed their minds, and other shoppers are blocked by items nobody is actually buying.

When some duplication is fine

Not every double-up is a problem, which is why blanket rules are unhelpful. Consumables, anything people run out of, and things it is genuinely useful to own two of are all fine. If a list says someone wants three of something, three people buying one each is the system working.

The ones that hurt are the single-instance items. Nobody needs two of the same book, and nobody needs a second identical gadget.

If it has already happened

Decide before the gift is opened, if you can. It is much easier to sort out quietly between two shoppers than in front of everyone.

• Whoever can return theirs most easily returns it, and buys something else off the list.
• If neither can, give one and keep the other for the next occasion.
• Do not make the recipient adjudicate it. Being handed two identical things and asked which to keep turns your admin problem into their awkward moment.

These get duplicated constantly, for the same reason: they are widely liked, easy to recommend, and cheap enough that two people can both act without checking.